You are here: Home > Main > Self-Report and Primary Care Medical Record Documentation of Mammography: RESULTS

Self-Report and Primary Care Medical Record Documentation of Mammography: RESULTS

All demographic data was self-reported and is shown in Table 1. Forty-two percent of the population were 40^9, 48% were 50-69, and 9% were over 70 years of age. Although all three racial/ethnic groups were represented at both clinics, 98% of Puerto Rican women presented at clinic 1, 94% of African-American women presented to clinic 2, and 81% of non-Latinas presented to clinic 2. Twenty-five percent of the women were currently employed, and 76% had household incomes less than $10,000 per year. Eighty-five percent of Puerto Rican women had a household income less than $10,000 compared to 74% of non-Latinas and 68% of African-American women (p=0.01). According to self-report, 37% of Puerto Rican women were mar ried or living with someone at the time of the interview compared to 22% of African-American women and 19% of non-Latinas (p=0.01). Interestingly, over half (56%) of the Puerto Rican women received less than an eighth-grade education compared to 17% of non-Latinas and 11% of African-American women (p<0.001). Based on self-report, non-Latinas were more likely to be uninsured compared to African-American women and Puerto Rican women, i.e., 16.5%, 7.1%, and 4.2%, respectively (p<0.001).

As shown in Table 2, women reported high rates of Pap smear utilization. High rates were also documented in the medical record. However, self-report of receiving a Pap smear within recommended guidelines was consistently higher than medical record documentation. There was a high level of agreement between self-report and medical record documentation for receipt of Pap smear according to recommended guidelines. These results were consistent across racial/ethnic groups. The sensitivity of reporting Pap smear use was high (92-99%), whereas the specificity was low (2.7-22.2%). The positive predictive value was high except for reporting more than one Pap smear. Negative predictive values were moderate, ranging from 20-56%. Sensitivity, specificity and positive predicative values were similar across racial/ethnic groups. However, negative predictive values were inconsistent across groups. kamagra soft tabs

Table 1. Patient Demographic Characteristics by Racial/Ethnic Group

Demographics

Total Non-Latina White African-American Puerto Rican P Value
N=314, % N=79, % N=114,% N=121,%
Age

NS

40-49

42.4

41.8

40.4

44.6

50-69

48.4

46.8

53.5

44.6

70+

9.2

11.4

6.1

10.7

Place of Care

O.001

Clinic 1

44.6

19.0

6.1

97.5

Clinic 2

55.4

81.0

93.9

2.5

Employment Status

NS

Employed

24.8

25.3

27.2

22.3

Unemployed

75.2

74.7

72.8

77.7

Income

0.013

<$ 10,000 per year

75.7

74.0

67.9

84.9

>$ 10,000 per year

24.3

26.0

32.1

15.1

Total Non-Latina White African-American Puerto Rican P Value
N=326, % N=80, % N=118,% N=128, %
Marital Status

0.01

Married/cohabitating

27.2

19.2

22.1

37.2

Single/never married

17.9

17.9

25.7

10.7

Divorced/separated

34.9

43.6

31.9

32.2

Widowed

19.9

19.2

20.4

19.8

Education

O.001

Eighth grade or less

29.7

16.5

10.6

56.2

Some high school

16.9

13.9

19.5

16.5

Сотр. high school

27.2

36.7

33.6

14.9

Some college/more

26.2

32.9

36.3

12.4

Insurance Coverage

O.001

None

8.4

16.5

7.1

4.2

Governmental

63.4

63.3

58.9

67.8

Medicaid/MCO

13.3

5.1

9.8

22.0

MCO/private

14.9

15.2

24.1

5.9

As shown in Table 3, positive self-report of mammography use was high for each category (93% for “ever had a mammogram,” 93% for “had a mammogram within recommended guidelines”, 87% for “had more than one mammogram” and 91% for “had a previous mammogram within recommended guidelines of the last one”). Self-report of mammography use was consistently higher than medical record documentation of use. Agreement between self-report and documentation in the medical record was 73% for “ever had a mammogram,” 65% for “last mammogram within the recommended guidelines,” 68% for “had more than one mammogram” and 47% for “mammogram prior to the last, within recommended guidelines.” Agreement was higher for more recent screening. These findings were consistent across racial/ethnic groups. However, chart documentation of “mammogram prior to the last, within recommended guidelines” was higher for non-Latinas (52%) and African-American women (48%) than Latinas (35%). Similarly, agreement between self-report and chart documentation of a “mammogram prior to last within recommended guidelines” was higher for non-Latinas (59%) and African-American women (52%) than Puerto Rican women (35%).
cheap prescription drugs online

Table 2. Percent Agreement between Self-Report and Medical Record Review in Documenting Pap Smear Utilization by Racial/Ethnic Group

Self Report Chart Percent Sensi- Specifi- Positive Negative
N(%) Review Agreement tivity city Predictive Predictive
n(%) n(%)

%

%

Value % Value %
Total
Ever had Pap

299 (98.4)

268 (88.2)

265 (87.1)

98.5

2.7

88.3

20.0

More than one Pap

253 (96.6)

167 (63.7)

168 (64.1)

97.6

5.3

64.4

55.6

Last Pap within three years

241 (96.0)

232 (92.4)

228 (90.8)

97.0

15.8

93.4

30.0

Pap before last within

145 (90.6)

142 (88.8)

135 (84.4)

92.3

22.2

90.3

26.7

three years
Non-Hispanic White
Ever had Pap

74 (98.7)

61 (81.3)

62 (82.6)

100

7.1

82.4

100

More than one Pap

60 (100)

34 (56.7)

34 (56.7)

100

0

56.7

0

Last Pap within three years

57 (95)

53 (88.3)

52 (86.7)

96.2

14.3

89.5

33.3

Pap before last within

29 (85.3)

26 (76.5)

27 (79.4)

92.3

37.5

82.8

60.0

three years
African American
Ever had Pap

112 (100)

100 (89.3)

100 (89.3)

100

0

89.2

0

More than one Pap

95 (95.0)

60 (60.0)

59 (59)

95.0

5.0

60.0

40.0

Last Pap within three years

92 (96.8)

91 (95.8)

88 (92.6)

96.7

0

95.7

0

Pap before last within

56 (98.2)

53 (93.0)

52 (91.2)

98.1

0

92.9

0

three years
Puerto Rican
Ever had Pap

113 (96.6)

107 (91.5)

103 (88.0)

96.3

0

91.2

0

More than one Pap

98 (96.1)

73 (71.6)

75 (73.5)

98.6

10.3

73.5

75.0

Last Pap within three years

92 (95.8)

88 (91.7)

88 (91.7)

97.7

25.0

93.5

50.0

Pap before last within

60 (87.0)

63 (91.3)

56 (81.4)

87.3

16.7

91.7

11.1

three years

Self-report of mammography use had high sensitivity (95-100%) and low specificity (9-26%). Positive predictive values were moderate (44.5-71.6%) and negative predictive values were high (75-95.5%). Sensitivity of self-report for mammography use was high across all racial/ethnic groups (88-100%). Specificity was low across all racial/ethnic groups except for self-report of “had more than one mammogram” among Puerto Rican women (32%). Positive predictive value of self-report for mammography use was moderate-to-high across racial/ethnic groups. The negative predictive values were consistently high across racial/ethnic groups except for “previous mammogram from the last within recommended guidelines” which was 100% for non-Latinas and African-American women but only 50% among Puerto Rican women. canadian antibiotics

Table 3. Percent Agreement between Self-Report and Medical Record Review in Documenting Mammography by Racial/Ethnic Group (N=314)

Self Report Chart Percent Sensi- Specifi- Positive Negative
N(%) Review Agreement tivity city Predictive Predictive
n(%) n(%)

%

%

Value % Value %
Total
Ever had mammogram (mam)

292 (93.0)

210 (66.9)

230 (73.3)

99.5

20.2

71.6

95.5

More than one mam

181 (86.6)

128 (61.2)

142 (67.9)

94.5

25.9

66.9

75.0

Last mam within guidelines

164 (91.1)

103 (57.2)

117 (65.0)

99.0

19.5

62.2

93.8

Mam before last within

110(93.2)

51 (43.2)

55 (46.6)

96.1

9.0

44.5

75.0

guidelines
Non-Hispanic White
Ever had mam

74 (93.7)

47 (59.5)

52 (65.8)

100

15.6

63.5

100

More than one mam

45 (95.7)

27 (57.4)

29 (61.7)

100

10.0

60.0

100

Last mam within guidelines

41 (91.1)

25 (55.6)

29 (64.5)

100

20.0

61.0

100

Mam before last within

25 (92.6)

14 (51.9)

16 (59.3)

100

15.4

56.0

100

guidelines
African American
Ever had mam

106 (93.0)

77 (67.5)

85 (74.5)

100

21.6

72.6

100

More than one mam

65 (84.4)

47 (61.0)

53 (68.8)

93.6

30

67.7

75.0

Last mam within guidelines

59 (90.8)

40 (61.5)

46 (70.7)

100

24

67.8

100

Mam before last within

40 (95.2)

20 (47.6)

22 (52.4)

100

9.1

50.0

100

guidelines
Puerto Rican
Ever had mam

112 (92.6)

86 (71.1)

93 (76.8)

98.8

22.9

75.9

88.9

More than one mam

71 (83.5)

54 (63.5)

60 (70.6)

92.6

32.3

70.4

71.4

Last mam within guidelines

64 (91.4)

38 (54.3)

42 (60.0)

97.4

15.6

57.8

83.3

Mam before last within

45 (91.8)

17 (34.7)

17 (34.7)

88.2

6.3

33.3

50.0

guidelines

Related Posts

Tags: , , , ,

  • Digg
  • Del.icio.us
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Twitter

Leave a Reply

CAPTCHA image